Simon Dickson, principal consultant at Puffbox, writes stuff about e-government, online news and politics. Some important people read it.

Tom Watson’s ‘mashed up’ speech

11 March 2008 2 , , , , ,

OK, I'm an idiot. The lengthy and fair-minded piece I wrote this morning about a speech by Tory shadow chancellor George Osborne at the RSA was a year late.

Osborne made some interesting points about the need 'to recast the political settlement for the digital age.' And now today, there's an email doing the rounds (see Nick Booth's piece) pointing out similarities between this 2007 speech and the one made by Tom Watson on Monday. Amusingly, it condemns the Watson speech as a 'mashup'. But hold on. Surely it's entirely in keeping with the whole ethos of open source, to take good ideas and build on them? Didn't you say mass collaboration was a good thing? :)

OK, I'm being churlish. But this points to the biggest single hurdle in 'politics 2.0', or whatever we're calling it. Inevitably, roughly once every four years, every politician's worst instincts will come out as they fight for power or survival. You can't blame them. That's the adversarial, winner-takes-all political system we're currently stuck with.

And that's ironically why we need the apolitical Civil Service to take a lead on use of these collaborative technologies.

  • i like the adversarial system.
    Anyway, who cares? We are governed by the unadversarial Commission now.

  • [...] refreshing admission by Simon Dickson: OK, I’m an idiot. The lengthy and fair-minded piece I wrote this morning about a speech by Tory [...]

Got something to say? Say it.

Stop wasting your time RSS feed

Let us tell you when there's new stuff to read at puffbox.com, by subscribing to the RSS feed.

Go on, show your face

If you want your photo to appear beside any comments you leave here, hop over to Gravatar and upload a picture of yourself. Otherwise, we'll just assume the machine-generated monster is a fair likeness.

Tag cloud

Puffbox.com archives

Search

Alan's comments feed

By popular demand: the comments feed

Ancient history

For posts during 2006 or 2007, Simon's old blog's archives are still available.