Simon Dickson, principal consultant at Puffbox, writes stuff about e-government, online news and politics. Some important people read it.

When two blogs go to war

26 March 2009 2 , ,

draperguido

In the red corner, fighting out of Berkeley, California, the challenger - Derek Draper. His opponent, heavyweight champion of the Blogosphere, Paul 'Guido' Staines. Your referee for this afternoon's contest is Mr Andrew Neil.

When the BBC's Daily Politics finally brought two of political blogging's most inflammatory characters face to face, sparks inevitably flew: see the full five minute interview here. It wasn't especially enlightening: really just a chance to reheat the old, and frankly embarrassing playground spats of the past couple of months. That's fine for a self-proclaimed 'anti-politician' like Staines; but not for someone like Draper, who's supposedly trying to do something more edifying.

I was bemused by Derek's continuing efforts to present LabourList as independent of the party, particularly this exchange on funding:

AN: Who finances you?
DD: Well, we publish every year who finances us...
AN: Who does?
DD: Well, we haven't published it yet.

Or this remarkable about-turn:

DD: The blog is a collection of individuals...
AN: You don't have a collective view?
DD: No, of course not! LabourList sometimes posts as LabourList...
AN: So it does have a view?
DD: Yeah, it has a view.

Then, as the interview approached a conclusion, Derek tries to turn the funding questions back on Staines: 'When you set up Order Order, you were just out of being bankrupt, or a bankrupt. So where did the money come from?' What, to set a rudimentary blog at Blogspot.com, Derek? To buy a domain name? And a Skype account? Actually, that statement probably reveals a lot about the Labour Party's approach to internet activity. I'll say no more.

Meanwhile, on the respective blogs, it's getting very ugly. LabourList chose today to publish a dossier on Paul Staines, detailing 'a shocking story of bankruptcy, law-breaking and friendliness towards the BNP' - at least two of which, I'd have said, are totally irrelevant. Meanwhile, Staines has been out to California to do some dirt-digging into Draper's educational background, with disappointing results both in terms of the lack of a confirmed allegation, and the quality of his video. Interestingly, for the first time I think, Staines has cast aside the Guido persona for both today's TV slot and his YouTube video... continuing his journey into the mainstream media. One wonders where he's heading?

  • All of this has one up-side: it means that everyone else can get on with their (online) lives safe in the knowledge that Guido will have enough on his hands keeping Draper quiet that he won't be poking his nose in elsewhere.

  • Not quite his first outing - I was on a discussion panel with Paul at the Frontline Club a little while ago and he'd put aside his mask. Not exactly MSM but a public arena.

    http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/515103

Got something to say? Say it.

Stop wasting your time RSS feed

Let us tell you when there's new stuff to read at puffbox.com, by subscribing to the RSS feed.

Go on, show your face

If you want your photo to appear beside any comments you leave here, hop over to Gravatar and upload a picture of yourself. Otherwise, we'll just assume the machine-generated monster is a fair likeness.

Tag cloud

Puffbox.com archives

Search

Alan's comments feed

By popular demand: the comments feed

Ancient history

For posts during 2006 or 2007, Simon's old blog's archives are still available.